Choose one of the following questions to write about.
Question One:
In Alan Bowne’s 1985 play Beirut the lower east side of Manhattan
has been isolated as a quarantine zone. There is an unnamed plague
among the population which fits all the 1980’s worst fears of a super
communicative AIDS. As a result, the U.S. has become
something of a police state dividing people in to “Positives” those
with the plague and “Negatives” those who are unaffected.
Two weeks ago, the governor Edwards of Louisiana was describing
plans for reopening businesses in the state. He said testing for Covid
19 was essential so that
employers would know which employees had had Covid 19 and were
immune and which employees were not. That way the employees who were
immune could be put in the jobs in at the front desk and have contact
with customers and others while the employees who
had not had the virus could be put in jobs “in the back.”
Imagine what this plan could mean for different people? What kind of
segregated spaces might be created for “Exposed” and “Unexposed”
persons? Does this allow a discrimination against people who due to age,
or preexisting condition can not endure Covid 19 and
acquire that immunity? Does it count as a disability if one cannot risk Covid exposure?
Feel Free to read the play,
Or watch the film Daybreak that was based on it.
Question 2:
We talked some in class about the potential for
social differences among cyborgs “What happens if I can afford to get
the cybernetic arm with sensory connections that’s sleek metal and
glass, but you get the prosthetic
hook?” Let’s take this idea further and consider what happens as
prosthetics/cybernetics move even further out of health care into the
consumer market. We already see this as the case in how for example
health insurance will cover glasses and contacts but
not corrective eye surgery unless it is life threatening. But for this
question let’s consider cybernetic limbs and implants of inorganic
nature. Most consumer products are designed planned obsolescence. Think
about how long a pair of shoes, or an automobile
last. Don’t even get me started on the short life of a computer or a
smart phone. These revolutionary technologies that change the world yet
in only perform for a couple of years before it’s time to upgrade. What
happens when cybernetics and prosthetics need
t be upgraded every couple of years? Will there be easily detachable cybernetics, or will people repeatedly need to go under the knife?
Last night my smart TV froze because it needed a firmware update
that took a half an hour. It was frustrating because I wanted to play a
fifteen-minute exercise video, a minor irritation. But what if your
smart arm stops responding while it connects
to the cloud. . . while you’re on the freeway?
Also consider how so much technology has moved to the subscription
model? These days we own less and less. We subscribe to movies, to
music, essential applications. What would it be like if we have to
license a part of our own body? What if we can no longer
afford that low monthly subscription of $9.99 for our eye, our leg, our
liver?
This week, I read Manny's blog and particularly liked that it felt like Manny wasn't able to come to a clear decision on how he felt about separating people who are immune to Covid-19 and who aren't. The United States is mixed up in a whole lot of racism, discrimination against gender, sexuality, religion, and more that this kind of purposeful separation could easily be used to oppress minorities. Manny's wrestling with this is a reflection on how no answer is simple to trudging through this year until we have a vaccine for Covid-19. Being somewhat like the flu, but without a vaccine or any kind of medical protection against it, it also runs the risk of affecting people in their workplace who get sick with other illnesses. I think ultimately, whatever happens in this regard, the future is totally unknown as this is all uncharted territory.
ReplyDeleteDepressingly, all I can think in response to this line
ReplyDelete"Otherwise casualties from electronic/digital parts of the body will become a daily thing." in Victoria's post was "...yeah, that is exactly what is going to happen in the end" I think the world is well primed to accept death as a side-effect of convenience.